| Year | Location | Moderator |
| 1915 | Los Angeles | Walter M. White |
| 1914 | Atlanta | Hill M. Bell |
| 1913 | Toronto | Fred A. Henry |
| 1912 | Louisville | C. M. Chilton |
| 1911 | Portland | Harry D. Smith |
| 1910 | Topeka | Peter Ainslie |
| 1909 | Pittsburgh | Charles S. Medbury |
| 1908 | New Orleans | R. A. Long |
| 1907 | Norfolk | George H. Coombs |
| 1906 | Buffalo | S. M. Cooper |
| 1905 | San Francisco | E. I. Powell |
| 1904 | St. Louis | Z. T. Sweeney |
| 1903 | Detroit | A. B. Philputt |
| 1902 | Omaha | H. O. Breeden |
| 1901 | Minneapolis | I. J. Spencer |
| 1900 | Kansas City | W. K. Homan |
| 1899 | Cincinnati | W. F. Richardson |
| 1898 | Chattanooga | F. D. Power |
| 1897 | Indianapolis | M. M. Davis |
| 1896 | Springfield | J. M. Hardin |
| 1895 | Dallas | Jabez Hall |
| 1894 | Richmond | J. W. Allen |
| 1893 | Chicago | George Darsie |
| 1892 | Nashville | A. M. Atkinson |
| 1891 | Allegheney | D. R. Ewing |
| 1890 | Des Moines | T. M. Phillips |
| 1889 | Louisville | N. S. Haynes |
| 1888 | Springfield | J. H. Garrison |
| 1887 | Indianapolis | C. L. Loos |
| 1886 | Kansas City | F. M. Drake |
| 1885 | Cleveland | L. L. Carpenter |
| 1884 | St. Louis | A. G. Thomas |
| 1883 | Cincinnati | D. R. Dungan |
| 1882 | Lexington | B. B. Tyler |
| 1881 | Indianapolis | Robert Moffett |
| 1880 | Louisville | T. P. Haley |
| 1879 | Bloomington | W. H. Hopson |
| 1878 | Cincinnati | A. I. Hobbs |
| 1877 | St. Louis | W. K. Pendleton |
| 1876 | Richmond | Isaac Errett |
| 1875 | Louisville | Isaac Errett |
| 1874 | Cincinnati | R. M. Bishop |
| 1873 | Indianapolis | R. M. Bishop |
| 1872 | Louisville | R. M. Bishop |
| 1871 | Cincinnati | R. M. Bishop |
| 1870 | Indianapolis | R. M. Bishop |
| 1869 | Louisville | R. M. Bishop |
| 1868 | Cincinnati | R. M. Bishop |
| 1867 | Cincinnati | D. S. Burnet |
| 1866 | Cincinnati | Alexander Campbell |
| 1865 | Cincinnati | Alexander Campbell |
| 1864 | Cincinnati | Alexander Campbell |
| 1863 | Cincinnati | Alexander Campbell |
| 1862 | Cincinnati | Alexander Campbell |
| 1861 | Cincinnati | Alexander Campbell |
| 1860 | Cincinnati | Alexander Campbell |
| 1859 | Cincinnati | Alexander Campbell |
| 1858 | Cincinnati | Alexander Campbell |
| 1857 | Cincinnati | Alexander Campbell |
| 1856 | Cincinnati | Alexander Campbell |
| 1855 | Cincinnati | Alexander Campbell |
| 1854 | Cincinnati | Alexander Campbell |
| 1853 | Cincinnati | Alexander Campbell |
| 1852 | Cincinnati | Alexander Campbell |
| 1851 | Cincinnati | Alexander Campbell |
| 1850 | Cincinnati | Alexander Campbell |
| 1849 | Cincinnati | D. S. Burnet |
Offering received Sept. 26 & Oct. 3